NewTeardown No. 001: how a Bali developer turns strangers into $200K investors.Teardown No. 001: How to build a cityRead it
Resources  /  AI Search & GEO
AI Search & GEO

How to Evaluate a GEO Agency: A Practical Checklist Before You Hire

Two agencies can quote for “AI visibility” and deliver very different work. Here’s how to find out which proposal fits your buyers, your budget and the people available to put it into practice.

Albert Westin Lie
Co-founder, COO · Nov 20, 2026 · 12 min read
On this page4 sections
How to Evaluate a GEO Agency: A Practical Checklist Before You Hire

Give your two finalists a question a prospect asked before requesting a quote. For a US manufacturer, it might be “Which packaging equipment suppliers have a service technician in Ohio?” Ask each agency to show you the answer a buyer sees, the page behind the recommendation and the first change it would make. You can learn more from that exchange than from comparing two forecasts of how often AI will mention your brand.

A generative engine optimization (GEO) agency is a good fit when it understands how your buyers choose, can carry out the changes you need and can show you what happened afterward. GTMLab publishes this guide and is one of the providers discussed below.

Which GEO Agencies Belong on your Shortlist?

Consider GTMLab if leads depend on buyers finding the right service, location or distributor and you want to track the enquiry that follows.

Our AI search and SEO service includes work on buyer questions and the pages that answer them. If you sell B2B software and want a provider with a named client example in your category, Omniscient Digital’s work with Convert gives you a concrete project to examine.

Start with a one-page brief. Name the customer, the market and the action that matters to sales. For the equipment supplier, that could be a qualified request for a service quote.

Give each finalist the same non-branded question and ask them to run it in the buyer’s market and language. Save the date, the engine and the wording. Our guide to choosing GEO prompts explains how to build that first set from customer conversations.

Read the answer as the prospect would. If it cites your maintenance guide but sends the buyer to a competitor for installation, you have two different findings. Ask each agency which one it would act on, which page it would change and who can confirm the coverage claim. That is a useful test even for a small marketing team with budget for only one project.

What Will The First Contract Cost, and What Does it Cover?

Get the recurring fee, the minimum commitment and anything your team must buy or build separately, all in writing. A monthly quote is easy to compare. The harder question is whether it includes someone to fix the pages the audit identifies.

GTMLab’s published pricing lists its AI Search Essential plan at US$499 a month for an initial six months, then month to month. That puts the first six months at US$2,994 in base fees.

The plan lists 40 prompts checked weekly in ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews and Gemini, plus a visibility report every two weeks. If Google AI Mode is essential to your brief, ask for it explicitly.

Omniscient Digital’s engagement FAQ lists full-service engagements starting at US$120,000 per year. That figure describes a broader engagement.

Ask what part of the quote covers AI search, what content and technical work the agency will implement, and what term applies to your proposal. A buyer comparing these two published figures still needs an itemized scope from each team.

How to Compare the Commercial Terms

If the proposal offers…Ask the provider to put this in writing
A fixed-price starter projectThe pages or prompts covered, the fee, the delivery date and the files you keep.
A trial or paid pilotAvailability, the end date, the output you can inspect and whether the agreement automatically renews.
An ongoing retainerMonitoring frequency, platforms, implementation hours or deliverables, tool fees, cancellation terms and who can export the history.

If an agency offers a performance guarantee, read the clause before valuing it. Which questions qualify? Does a mention count if the answer recommends another provider? What happens to the fee if the target is missed? The answers matter more to your budget than the word “guaranteed.”

What your first 90 days should buy

By day 30, ask for the saved baseline and a short list of changes with owners. By day 60, ask to open a page or listing that was actually updated. By day 90, rerun the original questions and review what buyers now see. Set those checkpoints against your approval and development schedule. A team waiting six weeks for a release will need a different timetable.

What evidence should you see before signing?

Omniscient reports that Convert’s visibility across its tracked prompts rose from 31% to 55% in 60 days. That makes the published Convert case useful for a software buyer. To judge whether that work resembles your own brief, ask which questions were tracked, how many valid answers were collected and whether the increase included recommendations for a buying decision you care about.

Ask to see a report as well as a case study. GTMLab’s public AI visibility check shows an illustrative report layout. For a buying decision, request a redacted client example that connects a dated answer to the source cited, the change made and the follow-up check. Keep brand mentions, recommendations and links to your domain separate. For visits and qualified enquiries, ask what analytics and sales can actually trace. Our guide to GEO for lead generation explains that handoff.

If you already have an SEO partner, put both teams on the same page. The GEO agency might find that a buyer is being sent to the wrong location. Operations can verify the service area, your existing SEO partner can publish the fix, and the GEO agency can retest it. For a Google AI Overview issue, first check whether the page is indexed and eligible for a snippet. Google’s guidance describes those requirements.

A scorecard for the final two proposals

Give each criterion 0 if the evidence is missing, 1 if the answer is partial and 2 if the agency shows relevant evidence and can explain who owns the work. Record the document or example behind each score.

CriterionWhat earns a 2
Buyer fitA relevant market, buying question and commercial outcome.
Prompt selectionA dated baseline with its exact wording, engine and market.
ImplementationA specific page change and someone with access to publish it.
Case evidenceA comparable project with a baseline, timeframe and observed result.
MeasurementA sample report with valid answer counts and clear lead definitions.
Cost and ownershipWritten fees, a 90-day plan, export rights and handover terms.

A score out of 12 helps you see where the proposals differ. If both agencies score well, give them one final task. Ask who will correct the Ohio service page, when the edit can go live and what they will show you at the next review. Choose the team whose answer your staff can put into practice.

If GTMLab is on your shortlist, share one question your buyers ask before they request a quote. We can use it to discuss where your business appears in AI answers, what we’d change first and how we’d measure progress.

Explore a partnership

Let’s engineer your lead generation engine.

More qualified leads, lower CAC, and a clear view of which ads bring in revenue.

Ways to work with us
Monthly plansOne-off buildsGrowth partnership

How we start

  1. Discovery callWe learn how you sell, where leads go cold and what could work better.
  2. Read-only auditIf we’re a fit, we get read-only access to your ads, analytics and CRM, and diagnose what’s really going wrong.
  3. Your proposalWe walk you through the diagnosis and the engine we’d build to fix it.

For lead generation businesses already running paid ads. Replies within 24 hours.

Explore a partnership
Selected clients
LazadaCinepolisIHH HealthcareGleneaglesMount ElizabethSiloamELSA SpeakCekatAIAshley GroupBluuuCentral WellnessDoré by LeTaoGoDrinksIkigaiMediflyPalma Islands